The Enfield Saints created the Golden Shield award along with the Golden Boot, Golden Eye, Golden Glove, Player of the Season and Goal of the Season awards on 6 August 2013. The Golden Shield goes to the player with the most defender clean sheets in a season, the Silver Shield goes to second place and the Bronze Shield to third. The award is given out at the end of every season.
The following table is a list of winners of the Golden, Silver and Bronze Shield per season, detailing their defender clean sheet tally, games played, and their defender clean sheet ratio.
|2011–2012||Sam Curtis||19||57||0.33||Guy Hunt-Davison||13||40||0.32||Not given|
|2012–2013||Andrew Martin||38||76||0.5||Alfie O'Brian||28||58||0.48||Ashley Standland||16||32||0.5|
|2013–2014||James Pettit||8||12||0.66||Dylan Rafferty||4||5||0.8||Kris Storey-Jones||3||5||0.6|
|2014–2015||Jason Gruber||13||42||0.30||Dylan Rafferty||4||7||0.57||Sam Curtis||1||2||0.5|
|2015–2016||Sam Curtis||17||72||0.23||Peter Hunt||14||33||0.42||Dylan Rafferty||10||28||0.35|
|2016–2017||To be determined||To be determined||To be determined|
"Not Given" indicates an award not given due to there being no player with sufficient Defender Clean Sheets..
| Wins by Player
| Wins by Country