The Enfield Saints created the award along with Player of the Week award and Player of the Month award in 2011, it was given out at the end of every year at midnight GMT (UK time). On 6 August 2013, it was annouced that a new award, the Player of the Season award, would take it's place and this time be given out each season not year.
- The Awards "Not Given" are due to a tie of votes, there was no fair or decisive way to determine who deserves the award.
- "Not available" is shown where no matches were played.
|2011||Daniel Lewis||Not given|
|2012||Daniel Lewis||Bobby Lewis||Jason Gruber|
|2013||Daniel Lewis||Bobby Lewis||Reno Loughlin|
|Award replaced with the Player of the Season award from 2014 onward.|
| Wins By Player
| Votes For Player
| Wins By Country
| Votes For Country